Does God Reward?
People who believe in God usually believe he gives rewards. This doctrine is
full of contradictions and hypocrisy.
Psychologists have shown that talented kids who are rewarded by praise for their achievements tend to get fairly careless after. That is because they get complacent and forget they have to keep working at their talent. It is also because they care more about the praise than what they are praised for.
However, once you praise people for making a good effort they will drive themselves harder and for longer and more consistently.
A God who rewards you for your achievements is not truly a good God. Jesus in the parable of the sheep and goats praised the achievements of the sheep and rewarded them.
Believers in God expect rewards.
Some admit they want these rewards.
Others boast that they would do the good they do if there were no rewards.
Both camps then seek rewards. Those who say they don't care about rewards are
boasting and boasting is its own reward.
It is more humble to do a good work in front of an audience than to say a thing
like that!
Some say they don't care about rewards but want God to be a rewarding God for
they want their loved ones to be rewarded. They claim to be the kind of people
that would be willing to let God take away their chance of Heaven if it meant
letting their loved ones go to Heaven. That is another boast.
Also, if rewards are so bad and being selfless so good surely if you did not
want rewards you would not want them for your loved ones? You would want them to
be totally unmotivated by the desire for rewards as they do their good deeds.
If God exists then he comes first for he is goodness. The highest goodness is
doing good with no reward except the thought that it is the will of God. But
then religion says God rewards in Heaven which would mean you are getting
rewards that are not rewards at all but insults for they mean nothing to you but
doing what God wants does. Belief in God is incompatible with belief in real
rewards.
The Catholic Church teaches that a single instant of submission to the will of
God as in, "Your will not mine be done" is worth more than several lifetimes of
good works. A religion like that is essentially fanatical and the world is
stupid to think the Church really values good works as much as it pretends. If
God rewards you then it is not so much for the good works you do as for your
belief in him and submission to him. The reward is essentially approval for your
madness.
There is no humility in a person who considers a prayer to be worth more than a
godless person serving the sick of the world.
The rewards God supposedly gives for praying and serving God are one of the
principal attractions in Christianity and Islam and the religions would not
exist without these bribes. Yet if God is really good he cannot give rewards.
Anyway, when those cults say you need grace to rise above your sinfulness and
that God is self-sufficient for he is all-powerful where is the satisfaction in
a reward that you get for a good work that God helped you to do for you could
not do good on your own? How can you be happy with a reward for a work that God
used you to do that did not then really come from you alone? God only rewards
what he did through you. Thus he is not really rewarding you.
To accept a reward for a selfless act is to say, “I did the good deed because it
was good but now I am treating it as if I did it for myself.” You are kind of
repenting of it and if self-sacrifice is sacred then your repentance is unholy
and wicked and insulting to the people you helped - even if they do not take it
that way. If you do good because it is good and not for a reward then you do not
approve if you would accept a reward for your ideal is to forget about what is
in it for yourself. So for God or anybody to reward you is to invite you to do
what you believe is wrong.
If it is bad to reward a selfless person then it is diabolically bad to
encourage people to believe in a God who rewards all good deeds. Expecting a
reward from people would not be as bad as expecting it from God for unlike him
they have to be selective in what good things they reward.
Religion says that truly good works are done for God and his honour. That is to
be the main or only motive. But God being almighty and all-powerful does not
need anything from us. You did your good work for God who does not need it and
when the good is that meaningless what pleasure could you take in the reward? If
you do take pleasure then you are deceiving yourself. You would not be doing the
good just because it is good for all it is, is meaningless.
Virtue, according to the sages, is its own reward. Further rewards then are
unnecessary. People are to do good because it is good and so rewards would be an
insult. Rewards would be necessarily inferior to the reward that is virtue so
there would be no point in giving them. When people put the desire for rewards
out of their minds the rewards are not rewards for they mean nothing to them.
They do not want the praise and thanks of others but for others to copy their
example and do their best. They would be offended to be praised.
If by reward you mean some kind of joy then
that doesn't fit Jesus who said that virtue brings a cross and
persecution. If virtue does not promise good feelings or
necessarily open the door to them at least then it is in no sense
its own reward. It is not a potential reward. If there
is a God then one day virtue will be its own reward. This
shows how the atheist or one who does not believe a reward is
waiting for you even if you cannot get your hands on it is
potentially the best person when they do good works.
A reward must fit the deed. Any more “reward” is a gift not a reward. Christians
arrogantly think they are going to get an everlasting reward for maybe giving
somebody a cup of water! How humble! It shows great cynicism to think that
people can't do good unless they are bribed with an everlasting reward!
If God exists then he comes first for he is goodness. The highest goodness is
doing good with no reward except the thought that it is the will of God. But
then religion says God rewards in Heaven which would mean you are getting
rewards that are not rewards at all but insults for they mean nothing to you but
doing what God wants does. Belief in God is incompatible with belief in real
rewards. Yet people have been tricked by the Church to think they should
encourage belief in God so that people will do good thinking they will get a
reward. Without the doctrine of rewards, people would say that the God belief is
pointless. That says plenty about them!
Expecting a heavenly reward and going among the poor to work for nothing is not
being unselfish or showing absence of self-interest. The self-interest is just
looked for a different way from the usual way. There is more self-interest in a
person who serves others for a permanent heavenly reward than one who does it
for a wage.
The craftiest form of selfishness or self-centredness is when people disguise it
as the service of God.